SCOTUS v. Public Opinion

What did a ruling change—and what did the public actually say?

Policy comparisons

10 worked examples pair specific rulings with earlier survey responses. These selected cases illustrate the comparison; they do not measure overall Court–public agreement.

How to read this comparison

Direct comparison: a question addresses a named policy component. Context only: related preferences, not approval of the specific holding. Missing data: no suitable earlier observation in this selection. Procedural rulings can be not comparable.

We use the latest eligible survey year per source within three years, keeping tied question variants. Same-year surveys are included only when verified fieldwork ends before the ruling. Percentages retain each survey’s wording and denominator; they are not pooled. Court interpretations are explicit source-based assessments, not automated classifications. Votes are not treated as policy magnitude.

These are historical outcomes. No causal, predictive, or statistical-significance claim is made. Missing matches do not mean no relevant survey exists elsewhere.

Marriage equality · A closer look

Should same-sex couples be allowed to marry?

Public support and legal protection changed over time. But permission to marry, recognition of a marriage, and equal treatment within marriage are different questions.

What the surveys tell us

Support rises between the selected 2012 and 2016 observations in CES, GSS and PRRI. The levels differ across sources, whose wording and response categories are not identical.

What the rulings tell us

General marriage preferences match Obergefell’s licensing ruling. Targeted Gallup and ABC/Post questions also address federal and interstate recognition. Birth-certificate rules still have only broad marriage-attitude context.

Public opinion over time · 1988–2024

Share supporting or agreeing with same-sex marriage in 28 audited source/question-year observations. Each bar runs from 0 to 100%. Sources are kept separate; missing years are not interpolated. This history includes surveys before and after the rulings; only eligible earlier surveys appear in the case comparisons below.

CES

Explore 5 observations · 2012–2016
2012 · gaymarriage_legalize53.7%
Wording and denominator

Do you favor or oppose allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally?

Support/oppose respondents only; harmonized missing answers excluded, original unsure/nonresponse categories unavailable here.

2013 · gaymarriage_legalize54.7%
Wording and denominator

Do you favor or oppose allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally?

Support/oppose respondents only; harmonized missing answers excluded, original unsure/nonresponse categories unavailable here.

2014 · gaymarriage_legalize56.0%
Wording and denominator

Do you favor or oppose allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally?

Support/oppose respondents only; harmonized missing answers excluded, original unsure/nonresponse categories unavailable here.

2015 · gaymarriage_legalize56.5%
Wording and denominator

Do you favor or oppose allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally?

Support/oppose respondents only; harmonized missing answers excluded, original unsure/nonresponse categories unavailable here.

2016 · gaymarriage_legalize61.6%
Wording and denominator

Do you favor or oppose allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally?

Support/oppose respondents only; harmonized missing answers excluded, original unsure/nonresponse categories unavailable here.

GSS

Explore 12 observations · 1988–2024
1988 · marsame10.9%
Wording and denominator

Homosexual couples should have the right to marry one another

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

2004 · marsame29.9%
Wording and denominator

Homosexual couples should have the right to marry one another

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

2006 · marsame135.4%
Wording and denominator

Homosexual couples have right to marry

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

2008 · marsame138.9%
Wording and denominator

Homosexual couples have right to marry

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

2010 · marsame146.3%
Wording and denominator

Homosexual couples have right to marry

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

2012 · marsame147.1%
Wording and denominator

Homosexual couples have right to marry

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

2014 · marsame156.0%
Wording and denominator

Homosexual couples have right to marry

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

2016 · marsame160.4%
Wording and denominator

Homosexual couples have right to marry

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

2018 · marsame166.6%
Wording and denominator

Homosexual couples have right to marry

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

2021 · marsame64.0%
Wording and denominator

Homosexual couples should have the right to marry one another

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

2022 · marsame66.2%
Wording and denominator

Homosexual couples should have the right to marry one another

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

2024 · marsame63.1%
Wording and denominator

Homosexual couples should have the right to marry one another

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

PRRI

Explore 9 observations · 2011–2024
2011 · Q8B48.2%
Wording and denominator

Allowing gay and lesbian couples to marry legally.

All positive-weight wave respondents, including unsure/refused/skipped and missing.

2012 · legssm48.4%
Wording and denominator

Allowing gay and lesbian couples to marry legally.

All positive-weight wave respondents, including unsure/refused/skipped and missing.

2013 · Q14A51.9%
Wording and denominator

Allowing gay and lesbian couples to marry legally.

All positive-weight wave respondents, including unsure/refused/skipped and missing.

2014 · Q12B48.6%
Wording and denominator

Allowing gay and lesbian couples to marry legally.

All positive-weight wave respondents, including unsure/refused/skipped and missing.

2015 · Q9A59.5%
Wording and denominator

Allowing gay and lesbian couples to marry legally.

All positive-weight wave respondents, including unsure/refused/skipped and missing.

2016 · Q22E64.2%
Wording and denominator

Allowing gay and lesbian couples to marry legally.

All positive-weight wave respondents, including unsure/refused/skipped and missing.

2017 · Q17A61.9%
Wording and denominator

Allowing gay and lesbian couples to marry legally.

All positive-weight wave respondents, including unsure/refused/skipped and missing.

2023 · Q40_E65.9%
Wording and denominator

How much do you favor or oppose each of the following? Allowing same-sex couples to marry legally.

All positive-weight wave respondents, including unsure/refused/skipped and missing.

2024 · Q10_C66.1%
Wording and denominator

How much do you favor or oppose each of the following? Allowing same-sex couples to marry legally.

All positive-weight wave respondents, including unsure/refused/skipped and missing.

VOTER

Explore 2 observations · 2016–2020
2016 · view_gaymar_201649.9%
Wording and denominator

Do you favor or oppose allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally?

Positive-weight administered wave respondents, including unsure/skipped; not-asked and system missing excluded.

2020 · view_gaymar_2020Nov56.4%
Wording and denominator

Do you favor or oppose allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally?

Positive-weight administered wave respondents, including unsure/skipped; not-asked and system missing excluded.

CES percentages exclude missing answers and use support/oppose respondents only. Other sources retain additional categories; differences between sources are not necessarily changes in opinion. See the response breakdowns below.

Why is VOTER lower in 2016?

VOTER records 49.9% favor, 35.1% oppose, 14.6% unsure and 0.3% skipped, using its supplied cross-sectional weights. Among favor/oppose respondents only, support is 58.7%; CES reports 61.6% on that narrower denominator. This explains most of their apparent difference, but does not make the surveys equivalent.

We verified VOTER’s raw response counts and weights against its survey guide. It interviewed returning panelists in November–December 2016. Differences from GSS and PRRI remain; timing, question format and sample design may matter, but we have not isolated their effects. The bars retain the original denominators.

What changed in court?

Selected decisions, not a complete legal history. Court outcomes are described in words, not positioned on a numerical ideology scale.

  1. Baker v. Nelson

    Appeal dismissed for want of a substantial federal question.

  2. Hollingsworth v. Perry

    No standing; Ninth Circuit judgment vacated, appeal to be dismissed

  3. United States v. Windsor

    DOMA section 3 is unconstitutional

  4. Obergefell v. Hodges

    States must permit same-sex couples to marry on equal terms

  5. Pavan v. Smith

    Rejected unequal treatment of same-sex spouses under Arkansas birth-certificate rules.

Explore the closest comparison: Obergefell ↓

The evidence, decision by decision

Baker v. Nelson

Read the decision ↗

Challenge to exclusion from marriage licensing

Missing data

Allows or maintains a restriction

Appeal dismissed for want of a substantial federal question.

Summary disposition left the challenged Minnesota judgment in place; not a new nationwide legislative prohibition.

Broad licensing-policy direction is comparable in principle, but this survey selection has no eligible pre-1972 observation.

No matching earlier survey response in this selection.

Holding source and scope

409 U.S. 810, October 10, 1972, docket 71-1027; PDF page 10. Obergefell Part III discusses and overrules Baker.

Summary dismissal has limited merits effect on the issues necessarily decided, unlike a standing dismissal. It does not adopt every rationale below. See Mandel v. Bradley, 432 U.S. 173, 176 (1977): https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/432/173 . Baker was later overruled in Obergefell Part III.

Hollingsworth v. Perry

Read the decision ↗

Initiative proponents' standing to appeal

Not comparable

Procedural ruling

No standing; Ninth Circuit judgment vacated, appeal to be dismissed

Article III appellate jurisdiction, not adjudication of whether states must permit same-sex marriage

Do not assign a policy-agreement score from marriage-legality responses

No policy-agreement score assigned.

Holding source and scope

Majority closing paragraph

The dissent concerns standing; it must not be coded as opposition to marriage equality.

United States v. Windsor

Read the decision ↗

Federal recognition of lawful same-sex marriages

Context only

Expands protection or access

DOMA section 3 is unconstitutional

Federal treatment of marriages lawful under state law; not a nationwide state licensing requirement

Broad marriage-legality preference is directionally relevant context, not a direct measure of support for DOMA section 3 invalidation

CES 2012

Do you favor or oppose allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally?

CES 2012 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support / agree53.7%
Oppose / disagree46.3%

Support/oppose respondents only; harmonized missing answers excluded, original unsure/nonresponse categories unavailable here.

Question details

Variable: gaymarriage_legalize · Weight: weight

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

GSS 2012

Homosexual couples have right to marry

GSS 2012 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support / agree47.1%
Oppose / disagree39.0%
Neutral12.1%
Unsure1.2%
Nonresponse0.5%

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

Question details

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Variable: marsame1 · Weight: wtssnrps

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

PRRI 2012

Allowing gay and lesbian couples to marry legally.

PRRI 2012 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support / agree48.4%
Oppose / disagree44.8%
Unsure6.8%

All positive-weight wave respondents, including unsure/refused/skipped and missing.

Question details

Variable: legssm · Weight: weight

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

Holding source and scope

Majority Part IV, final two paragraphs; syllabus holding 2

Jurisdiction despite executive agreement with Windsor

Not comparable

Procedural ruling

Court could consider the merits

Jurisdiction component only; the separate DOMA holding does decide merits

Not measured by marriage-legality questions

No policy-agreement score assigned.

Holding source and scope

Majority Part II; syllabus holding 1

Federal recognition of lawful same-sex marriages — targeted polling

Direct comparison

Expands protection or access

DOMA section 3 is unconstitutional

Federal treatment of marriages lawful under state law; not a nationwide state licensing requirement

Federal-recognition policy match; legislative remedy is not approval of constitutional reasoning.

Gallup 2013

Published topline · 2013-03-04 – 2013-03-05

Original report ↗ · page 2, item 1

Federal recognition of same-sex marriages for federal purposes and benefits.

Gallup 2013 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Favor48.0%
Against49.0%
No opinion4.0%

Published weighted percentages; includes no opinion. Rounded totals may equal 101%; values are not renormalized.

Question details

Question summary (paraphrased). See the original report for exact wording and questionnaire context.

Variable: marriage_topline_1 · Weight: Publisher-weighted topline; respondent-level weights unavailable

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

Holding source and scope

Majority Part IV, final two paragraphs; syllabus holding 2

Federal recognition of lawful same-sex marriages — targeted polling

Context only

Expands protection or access

DOMA section 3 is unconstitutional

Federal treatment of marriages lawful under state law; not a nationwide state licensing requirement

Narrower employee-benefits question; keep distinct from general federal recognition.

Gallup 2013

Published topline · 2013-03-11 – 2013-03-12

Original report ↗ · page 1, item 1C

Marriage benefits for federal employees legally married to same-sex partners.

Gallup 2013 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Favor54.0%
Against39.0%
No opinion8.0%

Published weighted percentages; includes no opinion. Rounded totals may equal 101%; values are not renormalized.

Question details

Question summary (paraphrased). See the original report for exact wording and questionnaire context. Report gives full-survey n and split forms; item-level sample size is not established.

Variable: marriage_topline_2 · Weight: Publisher-weighted topline; respondent-level weights unavailable

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

Holding source and scope

Majority Part IV, final two paragraphs; syllabus holding 2

Votes and dissent authors are not measurements of the justices' personal approval of marriage equality.

Obergefell v. Hodges

Read the decision ↗

State licensing of same-sex marriages

Direct comparison

Expands protection or access

States must permit same-sex couples to marry on equal terms

Nationwide constitutional requirement

Direct broad policy-direction comparison with allowing same-sex couples to marry; not approval of the constitutional reasoning

CES 2014

Do you favor or oppose allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally?

CES 2014 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support / agree56.0%
Oppose / disagree44.0%

Support/oppose respondents only; harmonized missing answers excluded, original unsure/nonresponse categories unavailable here.

Question details

Variable: gaymarriage_legalize · Weight: weight

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

GSS 2014

Homosexual couples have right to marry

GSS 2014 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support / agree56.0%
Oppose / disagree31.4%
Neutral11.1%
Unsure0.8%
Nonresponse0.8%

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

Question details

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Variable: marsame1 · Weight: wtssnrps

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

PRRI 2014

Allowing gay and lesbian couples to marry legally.

PRRI 2014 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support / agree48.6%
Oppose / disagree42.5%
Unsure8.8%

All positive-weight wave respondents, including unsure/refused/skipped and missing.

Question details

Variable: Q12B · Weight: weight

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

Holding source and scope

Majority Part III closing paragraph

Recognition of lawful out-of-state same-sex marriages

Context only

Expands protection or access

States must recognize these marriages

Interstate recognition

Related but not separately asked by selected broad marriage-legality questions

CES 2014

Do you favor or oppose allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally?

CES 2014 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support / agree56.0%
Oppose / disagree44.0%

Support/oppose respondents only; harmonized missing answers excluded, original unsure/nonresponse categories unavailable here.

Question details

Variable: gaymarriage_legalize · Weight: weight

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

GSS 2014

Homosexual couples have right to marry

GSS 2014 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support / agree56.0%
Oppose / disagree31.4%
Neutral11.1%
Unsure0.8%
Nonresponse0.8%

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

Question details

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Variable: marsame1 · Weight: wtssnrps

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

PRRI 2014

Allowing gay and lesbian couples to marry legally.

PRRI 2014 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support / agree48.6%
Oppose / disagree42.5%
Unsure8.8%

All positive-weight wave respondents, including unsure/refused/skipped and missing.

Question details

Variable: Q12B · Weight: weight

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

Holding source and scope

Majority Part V; syllabus holding c

Recognition of lawful out-of-state same-sex marriages — targeted polling

Direct comparison

Expands protection or access

States must recognize these marriages

Interstate recognition

Direct interstate-recognition policy match.

ABC News/Washington Post 2015

Published topline · 2015-04-16 – 2015-04-20

Original report ↗ · page 4, item 1c

Requiring states to recognize lawful same-sex marriages from other states.

ABC News/Washington Post 2015 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support62.0%
Oppose36.0%
No opinion3.0%

Published weighted percentages; includes no opinion. Rounded totals may equal 101%; values are not renormalized.

Question details

Question summary (paraphrased). See the original report for exact wording and questionnaire context.

Variable: marriage_topline_3 · Weight: Publisher-weighted topline; respondent-level weights unavailable

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

Holding source and scope

Majority Part V; syllabus holding c

State licensing of same-sex marriages — targeted polling

Direct comparison

Expands protection or access

States must permit same-sex couples to marry on equal terms

Nationwide constitutional requirement

Opposition to bans aligns with licensing access; preserve reverse wording.

ABC News/Washington Post 2015

Published topline · 2015-04-16 – 2015-04-20

Original report ↗ · page 4, item 1b

Allowing states to prohibit same-sex marriages.

Opposing this ban aligns with marriage access; support here means support for allowing bans.

ABC News/Washington Post 2015 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support36.0%
Oppose61.0%
No opinion4.0%

Published weighted percentages; includes no opinion. Rounded totals may equal 101%; values are not renormalized.

Question details

Question summary (paraphrased). See the original report for exact wording and questionnaire context.

Variable: marriage_topline_4 · Weight: Publisher-weighted topline; respondent-level weights unavailable

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

Holding source and scope

Majority Part III closing paragraph

Two components do not count as two independent decisions. Vote margin is recorded separately, never used as policy magnitude.

Pavan v. Smith

Read the decision ↗

Equal marital treatment on birth certificates

Context only

Expands protection or access

Rejected unequal treatment of same-sex spouses under Arkansas birth-certificate rules.

Application of equal marital benefits under Obergefell to the challenged birth-certificate treatment.

Marriage-legality questions provide broad context only. No selected item directly measures support for these birth-certificate rules.

CES 2016

Do you favor or oppose allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally?

CES 2016 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support / agree61.6%
Oppose / disagree38.4%

Support/oppose respondents only; harmonized missing answers excluded, original unsure/nonresponse categories unavailable here.

Question details

Variable: gaymarriage_legalize · Weight: weight

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

GSS 2016

Homosexual couples have right to marry

GSS 2016 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support / agree60.4%
Oppose / disagree26.9%
Neutral11.0%
Unsure0.8%
Nonresponse0.8%

Positive-weight respondents with substantive, cannot-choose or nonresponse item codes; inapplicable/year-unavailable/system-missing excluded.

Question details

Two wording variants kept distinct; Stata variable label is not full questionnaire context.

Variable: marsame1 · Weight: wtssnrps

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

PRRI 2016

Allowing gay and lesbian couples to marry legally.

PRRI 2016 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support / agree64.2%
Oppose / disagree34.7%
Unsure1.1%

All positive-weight wave respondents, including unsure/refused/skipped and missing.

Question details

Variable: Q22E · Weight: weight

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

VOTER 2016

Do you favor or oppose allowing gays and lesbians to marry legally?

VOTER 2016 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support / agree49.9%
Oppose / disagree35.1%
Unsure14.6%
Nonresponse0.3%

Positive-weight administered wave respondents, including unsure/skipped; not-asked and system missing excluded.

Question details

Variable: view_gaymar_2016 · Weight: weight_genpop_2016

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

Holding source and scope

Per curiam opening and closing paragraphs; dissent heading for author and joiners.

An unsigned opinion does not supply a named majority-joinder roster. Broad marriage approval is not measured approval of this birth-certificate holding.