SCOTUS v. Public Opinion

What did a ruling change—and what did the public actually say?

Policy comparisons

10 worked examples pair specific rulings with earlier survey responses. These selected cases illustrate the comparison; they do not measure overall Court–public agreement.

How to read this comparison

Direct comparison: a question addresses a named policy component. Context only: related preferences, not approval of the specific holding. Missing data: no suitable earlier observation in this selection. Procedural rulings can be not comparable.

We use the latest eligible survey year per source within three years, keeping tied question variants. Same-year surveys are included only when verified fieldwork ends before the ruling. Percentages retain each survey’s wording and denominator; they are not pooled. Court interpretations are explicit source-based assessments, not automated classifications. Votes are not treated as policy magnitude.

These are historical outcomes. No causal, predictive, or statistical-significance claim is made. Missing matches do not mean no relevant survey exists elsewhere.

Voter ID · A closer look

Should voters have to show photo identification?

A large majority supported the general requirement before Crawford. The Court left Indiana’s law in place, but the poll did not ask about that law’s particular rules.

What the public said

Pew asked adults nationwide in October 2006, about 18 months before the ruling. The complete response distribution appears below.

What the Court decided

In April 2008, a 6–3 judgment rejected the challenge to Indiana’s law as a whole. The six justices did not share a single rationale.

General support is not approval of every rule

The poll and the outcome point toward allowing photo ID. That does not tell us whether respondents accepted Indiana’s particular requirements or the burdens they imposed. This is one historical snapshot, not a trend or a measure of overall agreement on voting rights.

Federal oversight, ballot collection and photo identification are different policies. This comparison covers photo ID only.

The ruling and the earlier poll

Crawford v. Marion County Election Board

Read the decision ↗

Photo identification for in-person voting

Context only

Allows or maintains a restriction

Indiana’s photo-ID requirement remained in place after the Court rejected the facial challenge.

The judgment did not establish that every voter-ID law or every application of this law is constitutional.

The poll asks about photo ID generally. It does not specify Indiana’s exemptions, provisional-ballot process, or burdens on voters who lack qualifying identification.

Pew Research Center 2006

Published topline · 2006-10-17 – 2006-10-22

Original report ↗ · page 47, item 57

Should voters have to present official photo identification at the polls on Election Day?

Support means favoring a photo-ID requirement.

Pew Research Center 2006 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Should show photo ID78.0%
Should not have to do this18.0%
Don’t know / refused4.0%

All 2,006 adults in the survey, including don’t know/refused responses; not just registered voters. Published percentages retained without normalization.

Question details

Paraphrased question summary. Original question gives a driver’s license as an example. PDF page 47 (printed page 46), Q57, asked all respondents. Nationwide telephone survey of adults, including an oversample in competitive congressional districts; methodology on PDF page 15 and sample/date header on page 20.

Variable: pew_2006_q57 · Weight: Published national topline; no respondent-level recalculation or new weighting.

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

Holding source and scope

Stevens opinion, Parts III–IV; Scalia concurrence in the judgment; syllabus identifies the separate opinions.

Six justices agreed on the judgment, not one rationale. Stevens, Roberts and Kennedy relied on the record and the broad challenge; Scalia, Thomas and Alito concurred separately. Souter and Ginsburg dissented, as did Breyer separately. Public policy support does not settle the constitutional question.