SCOTUS v. Public Opinion

What did a ruling change—and what did the public actually say?

Policy comparisons

10 worked examples pair specific rulings with earlier survey responses. These selected cases illustrate the comparison; they do not measure overall Court–public agreement.

How to read this comparison

Direct comparison: a question addresses a named policy component. Context only: related preferences, not approval of the specific holding. Missing data: no suitable earlier observation in this selection. Procedural rulings can be not comparable.

We use the latest eligible survey year per source within three years, keeping tied question variants. Same-year surveys are included only when verified fieldwork ends before the ruling. Percentages retain each survey’s wording and denominator; they are not pooled. Court interpretations are explicit source-based assessments, not automated classifications. Votes are not treated as policy magnitude.

These are historical outcomes. No causal, predictive, or statistical-significance claim is made. Missing matches do not mean no relevant survey exists elsewhere.

Affirmative action · A closer look

The goal and the admissions rule are different questions

People can evaluate efforts to increase minority representation differently from a particular way of choosing applicants. These surveys ask about different policies; they do not yield one interchangeable approval score.

Before Fisher’s 2016 ruling

Pew asked whether programs to increase minority representation on campuses were good or bad. Gallup offered a choice between admission “solely on merit” and considering race and ethnicity for diversity. Neither described Texas’s particular admissions system.

Before the 2023 ruling

Pew asked specifically about race and ethnicity in selective-college admissions for diversity. That is closer to the policy at issue than general affirmative-action attitudes, but still does not measure approval of the Harvard and UNC decisions.

Before the 2023 ruling: race in selective-college admissions

Considering race and ethnicity in selective-college admissions to increase student diversity.

Pew 2023 admissions question, full response distribution
Published answerPercent
Strongly approve11%
Somewhat approve22%
Somewhat disapprove21%
Strongly disapprove29%
Not sure16%
No answer1%

Pew Research Center · 2023-03-27–2023-04-02 · 5,079 adults. Before the June 29 ruling; all response categories retained. Original report ↗

This question concerns the admissions policy directly, but does not describe Harvard’s or UNC’s particular programs. The broader VOTER question is available as background under the ruling below.

Before Fisher: two earlier questions, kept separate

Earlier polling for Fisher 2016 with original response categories
SurveyQuestion, summarizedPublished answers
Gallup · 2013Choosing admission based only on merit despite low minority enrollment, or considering race and ethnicity for diversity even if some minority applicants otherwise would not be admitted.Merit alone: 67%
Consider race / ethnicity for diversity: 28%
No opinion: 5%
Pew Research Center · 2014Whether affirmative-action programs intended to increase Black and minority representation on college campuses are good or bad.Good thing: 63%
Bad thing: 30%
Don’t know / refused: 8%

Different wording, field dates and survey designs. These results are not a trend or an experiment isolating a wording effect, and they are not averaged. Pew’s published 2014 percentages total 101% because of rounding.

What the comparison can tell us

Fisher upheld a particular use of race within holistic review alongside Texas’s percentage-admission pathway. Broad approval of campus representation and a forced choice about admission criteria do not resolve whether respondents supported that system.

The 2013 Gallup survey finished after Fisher’s first ruling, but before the 2016 ruling. A June–July 2016 Gallup survey straddled the second ruling and is excluded. Fisher’s 2013 remand remains unscored.

Selected rulings

  1. Fisher v. University of Texas (2013)

    Vacated and remanded for application of proper strict scrutiny.

  2. Fisher v. University of Texas (2016)

    Upheld the challenged race-conscious admissions plan under equal protection.

  3. Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard / UNC

    Invalidated the challenged race-conscious admissions programs.

The rulings and the earlier polls

Fisher v. University of Texas (2013)

Read the decision ↗

Standard of review and remand

Not comparable

Procedural ruling

Vacated and remanded for application of proper strict scrutiny.

The Court resolved the review standard without finally deciding whether this admissions plan was lawful.

General affirmative-action preferences do not decide how a court should apply strict scrutiny.

No policy-agreement score assigned.

Holding source and scope

Kennedy majority opinion Part III and closing paragraph.

This is not a final yes/no ruling on the program. The procedural label here refers to that policy comparison, not an absence of legal substance.

Fisher v. University of Texas (2016)

Read the decision ↗

Texas admissions program

Context only

Maintains legal permission

Upheld the challenged race-conscious admissions plan under equal protection.

Race as one factor in holistic review alongside a percentage-admission pathway; the Court upheld this particular program and record, not every racial preference.

Pew asks about increasing campus representation; Gallup asks about considering race against a merit-only alternative. Both concern higher education, but neither describes Texas’s percentage pathway, holistic review, or constitutional test. Keep the two questions separate and contextual.

Gallup 2013

Published topline · 2013-06-13 – 2013-07-05

Original report ↗ · page 3, item 24

Choosing admission based only on merit despite low minority enrollment, or considering race and ethnicity for diversity even if some minority applicants otherwise would not be admitted.

Policy preferences under this wording, not approval of Fisher or its constitutional reasoning.

Gallup 2013 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Merit alone67.0%
Consider race / ethnicity for diversity28.0%
No opinion5.0%

National sample of 4,373 adults; uncertainty retained in the published categories.

Question details

Paraphrased summary. The rotated alternatives frame a trade-off between merit and racial/ethnic consideration; this is survey wording, not the app’s claim that the two are mutually exclusive. National weighted results include oversamples of Black and Hispanic adults recontacted from Gallup Daily. Fieldwork straddles Fisher I (2013), so it cannot serve as earlier opinion for that ruling.

Variable: gallup_2013_Q24 · Weight: Published weighted national telephone-survey topline; no recalculation.

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

Pew Research Center 2014

Published topline · 2014-02-27 – 2014-03-16

Original report ↗ · page 3, item C127

Whether affirmative-action programs intended to increase Black and minority representation on college campuses are good or bad.

Policy preferences under this wording, not approval of Fisher or its constitutional reasoning.

Pew Research Center 2014 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Good thing63.0%
Bad thing30.0%
Don’t know / refused8.0%

National sample of 3,335 adults; uncertainty retained in the published categories.

Question details

Paraphrased summary. Asked all respondents. This describes a representation goal, not explicit race-based selection criteria or the Texas program. Published percentages total 101 because of rounding; do not calculate uncertainty as the residual 7%.

Variable: pew_2014_C127 · Weight: Published weighted national telephone-survey topline; no recalculation.

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

Holding source and scope

Kennedy majority opinion Parts II–III.

Different wording, years and survey designs prevent interpreting the percentages as a trend or an isolated wording effect. The 2013 Gallup and 2014 Pew fieldwork preceded Fisher II; Gallup’s June–July 2016 survey straddled the decision and is not used.

Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard / UNC

Read the decision ↗

Admissions and diversity — targeted polling

Context only

Restricts protection or access

Invalidated the challenged race-conscious admissions programs.

Limits those uses of race; does not prohibit considering an individual’s account of how race affected their life. Military academies were not decided.

The question isolates race and ethnicity in selective-college admissions for diversity. It does not describe Harvard’s or UNC’s particular programs, so this remains context rather than a case-approval estimate.

Pew Research Center 2023

Published topline · 2023-03-27 – 2023-04-02

Original report ↗ · page 32, item COLL_RE

Considering race and ethnicity in selective-college admissions to increase student diversity.

Approval of the described admissions policy, not approval of the constitutional reasoning.

Pew Research Center 2023 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Strongly approve11.0%
Somewhat approve22.0%
Somewhat disapprove21.0%
Strongly disapprove29.0%
Not sure16.0%
No answer1.0%

All 5,079 U.S. adults in the probability-based online panel survey; not sure and no answer retained.

Question details

Paraphrased summary. Asked all Wave 125 respondents. The question describes admissions and diversity specifically, but does not describe the Harvard or UNC programs. Methodology and full topline are in the report.

Variable: pew_2023_COLL_RE · Weight: Published weighted American Trends Panel topline; no recalculation.

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

Holding source and scope

Roberts majority opinion Parts III–VI; footnote 4.

Broader background: VOTER’s general affirmative-action question

Harvard and UNC admissions programs

Context only

Restricts protection or access

Invalidated the challenged race-conscious admissions programs.

Limits those uses of race; does not prohibit considering an individual’s account of how race affected their life. Military academies were not decided.

VOTER combines women and racial minorities and does not specify admissions. Its 2020 responses do not directly measure approval of the 2023 holdings.

VOTER 2020

Do you generally favor or oppose affirmative action programs for women and racial minorities?

VOTER 2020 weighted response percentages
ResponsePercent
Support / agree44.4%
Oppose / disagree33.5%
Unsure22.1%
Nonresponse0.0%

Positive-weight administered-wave answers, including unsure/skipped; not-asked/system missing excluded. The question combines women and racial minorities and does not isolate college admissions.

Question details

Variable: affirmativeaction_2020Sep · Weight: weight_genpop_2020Sep

Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.

Holding source and scope

Roberts majority opinion Parts III–VI; footnote 4.

The two companion cases are one displayed event, not two independent survey comparisons. Broad affirmative-action opinion cannot establish exact-case agreement.