Medical necessity as a defense for distribution
Context onlyAllows or maintains a restriction
The Court rejected a medical-necessity exception to the federal prohibitions on manufacturing and distributing marijuana.
A statutory question about the distributor’s defense, not a scientific judgment about medical benefit.
The poll asks about physician-directed medical use, not whether courts can recognize this defense under the statute.
Pew Research Center 2001
Published topline · 2001-02-14 – 2001-02-19
Original report ↗ · page 32, item 33
Allowing doctors to prescribe marijuana for medical treatment, separately from non-medical use.
Support concerns medically directed use, not general legalization.
| Response | Percent |
|---|---|
| Should be allowed | 73.0% |
| Should not be allowed | 21.0% |
| Don’t know / refused | 6.0% |
All 1,513 adults; don’t know/refused retained. Original percentages.
Question details
Paraphrased summary. Asked all respondents. National telephone sample with an African-American oversample; published weights adjust the sample. Methodology on PDF page 24; question on page 32 (printed page 31).
Variable: pew_2001_q33 · Weight: Published national weighted topline; no recalculation.
Zero or omitted categories do not establish that the original questionnaire lacked other answer options. Rounding may prevent totals of exactly 100%.
Holding source and scope
Thomas opinion, Part II; Stevens concurrence.